Architectural Recalibration #11: Donut City


If there’s one thing that has become apparent in recent weeks, it’s how quickly our set values and ideas can become outdated. This also applies to architectural concepts. ARCAM has begun to take stock of this for further consideration.

Amsterdam Donut City

7 juli 2020 – ‘Amsterdam to embracedonutmodel to mend post-coronavirus economy. The news in The Guardian is already three months old. At that timeduring the peak of the Corona outbreakit seemed logical to look into this topic more closely, once the post-coronavirus era had arrived. We soon realised that this was a rather naive thought, so we started working on it.

The model by British economist Kate Raworth aims for a circular, sustainable, social city, one which isn’t based on the classic economic model of (financial and spatial) growth, but on (ecological) balance and equality. And although Raworths role is importantas a source of inspiration and partner in developing knowledgethe Donut concept is formally taking shape in municipal policy for a circular city 20212025, which was adopted on 7 April and will continue into 2050.

But what does Donut City Amsterdam look like? Right now it seems like a lot of good intentions, ambitions, research, (small) cooperatives, and data linked to an implementation agenda (although we haven’t seen a single paragraph about financing). Still missing is a long-term spatial vision, akin to Amsterdam’s General Expansion Plan in the 20th century, or the Compact City concept.

A spatial model anchors and supports the behavioural change that Donut City Amsterdam aims to achieve, but can also help in making really tough choices. How is the Donut City connected to the need for a healthy, affordable housing market, with representation and inclusivity at every level? And what about all those companies that do want to grow and are not yet so circular, but are important to the city?

Perhaps that should begin with another metaphor. We could come up with a different delicacy to bring the image of the greasy, quintessentially American donut into more of a Dutch context. Balkenbrij, for instance: a cheap, particularly nutritious form of upcycled waste made into festive traditional food, from a time when circularity was still commonplace. Or the krakeling, with not one hole but two, within an infinitely circular shape.

To raise the connection to a spatial model, the falafel wrap is likely the most appealing example. After all, in this programmatically healthy, vegetarian, internationally oriented but locally anchored and versatile meal, a variety of ingredients are firmly held together by a neutral but very effective envelope. Just like the Donut City concept should be more than simply policy for circular food and the built environment, but also about the associated overarching design for sustainable, green, healthy, safe, and socially robust neighbourhoods.

We already have the ingredients. That’s mostly just a matter of collecting, weighing, and making the occasional difficult choice. Are we really getting rid of unhealthy companies? Is everyone actually allowed to participate in the city? The basis for the wrap is obvious, and right now we are diligently working on it. The conversation with the city about this is currently in full swing. Let the Environmental Vision for Amsterdam 2050 be the spatial basis for the Donut City.

Indira van ‘t Klooster – ARCAM-director


Associated

(NL) Architectonisch herijken #14 – Verveling

(NL) Nu we in een gedeeltelijke lockdown gaan, kunnen architecten tot voorbeeld dienen. Die kunnen zich namelijk niet vervelen.

(NL) Architectonisch herijken #13 – Jaarboek Architectuur

(NL) Deze tijd vraagt om gevoeligheid en inlevingsvermogen. En de reflecties van de redactie van het Jaarboek Architectuur blijken dit jaar ongekend...

Architectural Recalibration #12: Free Space

The disruptive power of the virus is slowly becoming apparent worldwide.

Architectural Recalibration #10: Housing Floor Plans

A critical review of the Timeline revealed that an incredible number of improvements have been made in Amsterdam between...

Architectural Recalibration #9: Dear White Architects

How woke are architects?

Architectural Recalibration #8: The Ornament

The need for a break out after the (first) outbreak rises and the urge for storytelling grows.

Architectural Recalibration #7: Superstructures

Even with the best of intentions, a grid is directive and prone to exclusion. So what about claiming public...

Architectural Recalibration #6: The architect in a lab coat

Architects enjoy positioning themselves as healers. Architectural recalibration #6: the architect in a doctor's jacket.

Architectural recalibration #5 – Proportions

Rooms, spaces, models, maps, satellite images, and photographs – size, scale, and proportions are an indispensable element for designers in...

Architectural recalibration #4 – Sensory design

Architectural Recalibration #4 delves into the art of sensory design.

Architectural recalibration #3 – Routing versus Dérive

Part three in the series Architectural recalibration examines the new concept of the 6ft society. 

Architectural recalibration #2 – Public domain

Examining the notion of Public Space in the Architectural recalibration series.

Architectural recalibration #1 – Home

In the coming weeks – working from home – ARCAM will be exploring the new world.