Architectural Recalibration #9: Dear White Architects


If there’s one thing that has become apparent in recent weeks, it’s how quickly our set values and ideas can become outdated. This also applies to architectural concepts. ARCAM has begun to take stock of this for further consideration.

#BlackLivesMatter anti-racism demonstration at Dam Square on June 1, 2020. Photo Lucas van der Rhee

8 June 2020 – The day Derek Chauvin put his knee on George Floyds neck was a day when news about the coronavirus faded into the background for a momentand yet, it didn’t. The wave of demonstrations caused by this event worldwide rarely went according to the 1.5 metre distancing guidelines. In Amsterdam, mayor Femke Halsema came under heavy fire. In other Dutch cities, protesters also foundlike funeral directors, churches, and mosquesa corona-resistant avenue to make their beliefs known. Black Lives Matter, also at a metre and a half. And within the context of the Dutch design sector, the question should be asked: how woke are architects, actually? And why is that important for the task of designing housing, retail, and public space? Architectural recalibration #9: Dear White Architects.

It is, in all fairness, a delicate topic. Even when ARCAMs own Architect in Residence, Lyongo Juliana, presented us with the plan for his residency, it took us a while to understand how deep the gap actually goes. How the taking for granted of white privilege creates blind spots, how difficult it is to constructively address inclusivity, and how important it is to have this uncomfortable conversation.

One of the ways NOT to do that, says Juliana, is to choose a title such as the one above this column. I initially wanted to name his entire residency that, precisely to make the gap visible, to confront. It would be analogous to the Netflix series Dear White People, which deals with just that: Students of colour face daily humiliations and underhanded scheming at an Ivy League university that is nowhere near as liberal as it thinks it is.

For Juliana, it is a delicate conversation (although he believes that a sterner approach is necessary at times). He tries to tempt his fellow countrymen into some form of understanding, but convincing them is perhaps a bridge too far. Because, certainly, there are designers with a bi-cultural background. And yes, the diversity on the office floor is increasing rapidlyat design agencies, too. But do they also have a joint say? Are their ideas heard, are their traditions analysed as a source of inspiration for contemporary design briefs?

What does, for example, the coronavirus mean for diversity and inclusion in the city? In his appearance at Pakhuis de Zwijger, Lyongo put it quite simply: We are not that different from one another, but we must realise that we each live in our own bubble. Failure to respond to those small differences can be disastrous. Architects need to observe better, form a picture of what people from a different cultural background want. They dont even have to understand. Just listen. There is a difference between being present and being heard. There is a difference between being tolerated and feeling involved. For those who think that this call is not relevant, the video below is telling. It is a recording taken from one week of a programme airing on Dutch news broadcaster NOS, in which various experts and others give their opinion on the impact and solutions for the coronavirus. What do you see?

Indira van ‘t Klooster – ARCAM-director


Associated

(NL) Architectonisch herijken #14 – Verveling

(NL) Nu we in een gedeeltelijke lockdown gaan, kunnen architecten tot voorbeeld dienen. Die kunnen zich namelijk niet vervelen.

(NL) Architectonisch herijken #13 – Jaarboek Architectuur

(NL) Deze tijd vraagt om gevoeligheid en inlevingsvermogen. En de reflecties van de redactie van het Jaarboek Architectuur blijken dit jaar ongekend...

Architectural Recalibration #12: Free Space

The disruptive power of the virus is slowly becoming apparent worldwide.

Architectural Recalibration #11: Donut City

What does Donut City Amsterdam look like?

Architectural Recalibration #10: Housing Floor Plans

A critical review of the Timeline revealed that an incredible number of improvements have been made in Amsterdam between...

Architectural Recalibration #8: The Ornament

The need for a break out after the (first) outbreak rises and the urge for storytelling grows.

Architectural Recalibration #7: Superstructures

Even with the best of intentions, a grid is directive and prone to exclusion. So what about claiming public...

Architectural Recalibration #6: The architect in a lab coat

Architects enjoy positioning themselves as healers. Architectural recalibration #6: the architect in a doctor's jacket.

Architectural recalibration #5 – Proportions

Rooms, spaces, models, maps, satellite images, and photographs – size, scale, and proportions are an indispensable element for designers in...

Architectural recalibration #4 – Sensory design

Architectural Recalibration #4 delves into the art of sensory design.

Architectural recalibration #3 – Routing versus Dérive

Part three in the series Architectural recalibration examines the new concept of the 6ft society. 

Architectural recalibration #2 – Public domain

Examining the notion of Public Space in the Architectural recalibration series.

Architectural recalibration #1 – Home

In the coming weeks – working from home – ARCAM will be exploring the new world.